|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Ecommerce is no longer just about having a checkout page. For enterprise organizations, it’s the backbone of complex operations, driving revenue, integrating with legacy systems, and supporting nuanced B2B and B2C models. While SaaS platforms like Shopify offer a quick on-ramp, they aren’t always built for the road ahead. The real question isn’t “which is better”—it’s “which is better for your business?”
That doesn’t mean custom ecommerce is always the answer. But for enterprises with specific needs around control, integration, and scalability, it just might be the smarter long-term play.
6 Key Considerations: Custom vs. SaaS Ecommerce
Here’s a look at where the decision points really lie, and how leading businesses have navigated this decision.
1. Scalability and Performance: When SaaS Starts to Strain
SaaS platforms are designed to serve the many, not the few. They work brilliantly, until your business grows beyond the “standard use case.”
As companies scale, including adding thousands (or millions) of SKUs, introducing high-traffic product discovery, or enabling sophisticated quote flows, platforms like WooCommerce and Shopify can start to show performance bottlenecks and architectural constraints.
2. Legacy Integration: When You Can’t Afford to Rip and Replace
Many enterprises can’t simply abandon their decades-old ERP or CRM systems. They need ecommerce platforms that integrate with existing infrastructure—not fight it.
Custom platforms can preserve complex integrations while modernizing the user experience, a critical factor for businesses with mission-critical systems that can’t be interrupted.
3. Business Model Complexity: More Than a Shopping Cart
SaaS platforms are built for conventional ecommerce: product, cart, checkout. But what if your business doesn’t fit that mold?
Complex B2B workflows—like quote-based transactions, role-based access, or branch-level budget allocation—often require bespoke logic and data models that off-the-shelf platforms weren’t built to handle.
4. Control and Ownership: Who Really Runs Your Business?
Using Shopify is a bit like renting a condo. You can decorate, maybe knock down a wall or two—but the building rules still apply. If Shopify changes pricing, limits API access, or sunsets a feature, you’re at their mercy.
With a custom ecommerce solution, you own the architecture, the IP, and the roadmap. You decide what gets built, when, and how. This is especially important when digital commerce and/or customer experience are core to your brand.
5. Security and Compliance: Don’t Leave It to Chance
SaaS platforms like Shopify are PCI-compliant by default, but that doesn’t mean they fit every compliance scenario. Custom development lets you build security into your architecture from the ground up.
For public institutions, regulated industries, or organizations handling sensitive data, custom platforms offer the ability to tailor privacy and security standards to exact requirements.
6. Dedicated, Responsive Support: The Bat Phone Advantage
With Shopify, you might get support from a chatbot, a help doc, or, if you’re lucky, a human response after a few days. With custom development and the right partner, you have a direct line.
Ongoing support becomes a collaborative relationship, with agile release cycles and prioritized backlogs that adapt to your business.
Real-World Use Cases: Why These Businesses Chose Custom
Sometimes the decision between SaaS and custom ecommerce isn’t theoretical—it’s painfully practical. Above, we touched on some common challenges that push enterprises to consider custom ecommerce.
Now, let’s take a closer look at two organizations—Miele and Whitehots—that reached those inflection points and chose custom ecommerce. Their stories demonstrate how custom solutions can deliver flexibility, performance, and long-term value when off-the-shelf options fall short.
Miele: Modernizing Legacy Systems for a Global Brand
Industry: Global appliance manufacturing and distribution
Business Model: B2C ecommerce with deep ERP dependencies
Miele Canada needed to modernize their digital commerce experience without disrupting mission-critical systems that powered their back office. The solution was a custom ecommerce platform built on Sitefinity, carefully architected to preserve the legacy database while introducing a modern content management system (CMS)—all without any disruption to business processes.
As a retailer, it is our responsibility to provide a consistent, and fully-integrated solution across all channels and touch points.
Marco Distler, Director, Digital Strategy & Consumer Insight, Miele Canada
The cutover was seamless, with no data loss, no disruption, and it enabled Miele to maintain local autonomy in Canada while aligning with a global CMS initiative. And, even better, customers think Miele is getting it right. In satisfaction surveys, customers give the manufacturer a 91% satisfaction rating for their online purchasing experience.
Why Custom?
- Preservation of integrations with legacy systems that needed to remain operational in their current state
- Complex appliance sales and multifaceted promotions
- Seamless user experience despite complex backend processes
- Allow Miele staff to directly manage content without impacting ecommerce operations
- Business continuity was non-negotiable—no room for downtime
Whitehots: Powering B2B Book Sales for Canada’s Libraries
Industry: B2B book distribution for libraries and schools
Business Model: Complex institutional purchasing with no online payments
Whitehots serves libraries across Canada—handling massive book catalogs, specialized pricing, and highly personalized ordering workflows. Their platform doesn’t include online payments, but enables users to build massive carts, allocate purchases across branches, apply special account codes, and even reference real-time inventory at individual libraries.
Built with a custom architecture, the B2B ecommerce platform supports millions of books and SKUs—not to mention complex metadata, multiple formats, pre-orders, and regional curation needs for libraries across Canada. Their custom solution delivers rich search functionality, hotlists, record generation, advanced filtering, and allows for massive cart sizes and allocations by branch or budget.
Their custom platform pulls real-time inventory data from libraries to prevent duplicate orders and creates custom data files (like MARC records) for ingestion into library cataloging systems. It also features dynamic integration with both Whitehots’ ERP and external library systems.
“The acceptance has been tremendous,” says Whitehots President Edmund Salt, adding one customer described working in the modernized Whitehots Hub as “life changing.”
Why Custom?
- Millions of SKUs, custom metadata, and pre-order logic
- No SaaS platform could handle allocation, budget codes, or MARC integration
- High compliance demands from publicly funded institutions
- Continuous agile development and release cycles tailored to client needs
Custom vs. SaaS Ecommerce: Key Considerations
Before you invest in a custom ecommerce platform, it’s important to weigh these key factors:
- Total Cost of Ownership: Beyond initial build costs, consider ongoing development, hosting, and support.
- Timeline for Development: A custom platform isn’t built overnight. Align timelines with your business goals.
- Integration Planning: Map out which legacy systems your platform needs to talk to—ERP, CRM, analytics, etc.
- Choosing the Right Partner: Look for a partner with deep technical experience, business acumen, and a collaborative approach to support.
How We Help Enterprise Ecommerce Clients
At Whitecap, we specialize in complex, custom ecommerce solutions that scale with your business.
Here’s how we help:
- Custom Development Expertise: From architecture to deployment, we build solutions tailored to your goals.
- Support for Hybrid B2B/B2C Models: We understand the nuances of relationship-based and transactional ecommerce.
- Experience with Systems Integration: Legacy ERP? No problem. Modern CRM? We’ll connect it all.
- Performance at Scale: Whether it’s high traffic or high SKU volume, we build for speed, uptime, and responsiveness.
SaaS or Custom Ecommerce?
So… SaaS or custom? The takeaway here isn’t that Shopify is bad or that custom ecommerce is perfect. It’s that the right platform depends on your needs.
- If you’re a smaller retailer with limited complexity and want to get online fast, SaaS may be the perfect fit.
- But if your business is enterprise-grade, lives in a complex ecosystem, or relies on nuanced sales processes—custom ecommerce may offer the control, integration, and support you can’t afford to compromise on.
Ready to explore whether custom ecommerce is right for your enterprise? Let’s talk through your priorities and map out a solution that fits your needs today and tomorrow.